By Scott Hall and Phil Wiese
Businesses that use automated license plate recognition (ALPR) technology should take a fresh look at their compliance with California’s Automated License Plate Recognition law in light of three recent state and federal court decisions that have spurred a wave of new class action complaints and increased litigation risks for parking operators, shopping centers, property managers, and other businesses that use ALPR technology.
These three cases demonstrate the importance for ALPR operators and end-users to adopt and post a compliant ALPR policy. If a company does not have an ALPR policy in place, courts have held that a customer could be harmed by impairment of their “right to know” how any collected license plate data will be used, and have allowed those lawsuits to proceed past the pleadings stage and into discovery. On the other hand, if the company does have an ALPR policy, courts have required plaintiffs plead a higher actual harm standard, where a plaintiff must allege they suffered harm beyond a mere statutory violation.
California law requires ALPR operators and end-users to maintain reasonable security procedures and implement a usage and privacy policy governing the collection, use, maintenance, sharing, and dissemination of ALPR information.[1] The required policy must address specific topics, including authorized purposes for using ALPR information, who may access it, training requirements, security monitoring, sharing restrictions, data accuracy measures, retention periods, and destruction procedures. These policies must be publicly posted in writing, and, if the business has a website, conspicuously posted on that website. Plaintiffs harmed by an ALPR violation may recover actual damages, but not less than $2,500 in liquidated damages, along with potential punitive damages, attorneys’ fees, litigation costs, and injunctive relief. The question of what constitutes statutory harm has dominated the litigation landscape.
In the February 2026 Bartholomew v. Parking Concepts decision,[2] a plaintiff alleged that a parking garage operator collected his license plate information when he entered and exited a parking garage, but the operator failed to implement and make publicly available the required ALPR usage and privacy policy. The trial court sustained the parking garage operator’s demurrer, and the Court of Appeal reversed in part.
Importantly, the Court of Appeal centered its decision on “harm.” The ALPR statute authorizes a private civil action only by an individual “harmed” by a violation. The parking garage operator argued that a plaintiff must show misuse, mishandling, or measurable damages—not simply a lack of compliance with the statutory requirements. The Court of Appeal disagreed, concluding that collecting and maintaining ALPR information without implementing and making public the required policy could harm individuals by violating their statutory “right to know” who is collecting their ALPR data and how it is being used and maintained.
After the Bartholomew decision, plaintiffs’ firms filed a flood of putative class actions against businesses and property owners that allegedly used ALPR technology without the required policy. Complaints were even filed against businesses that had posted ALPR policies, but which plaintiffs asserted insufficiently described the statutorily required elements.
In July 2026, the California Court of Appeal handed businesses that use ALPR technology an important victory in Mata v. Digital Recognition Network, Inc.[3] There, the court held that a plaintiff must suffer actual harm to have standing to bring a claim under the ALPR statute.
The plaintiff in Mata brought a putative class action against an ALPR provider that housed more than nine billion license plate images in its ALPR system. Importantly, the defendant, Digital Recognition Network (DRN), collected and maintained the images pursuant to an ALPR usage and privacy policy that it adopted years earlier in 2015.
The plaintiff alleged a single cause of action for violation of the ALPR statute, conceding that DRN’s ALPR policy included the statutorily-required information, but arguing that the purpose of DRN’s policy was to “maintain the appearance of adhering” to the ALPR statute and “to pay lip service to privacy laws without having any intention of actually complying with them.” Crucially, plaintiff did not plead, and could not prove, that he suffered any actual harm. DRN acknowledged that it captured the plaintiff’s license plate data at least 15 times, but argued on summary judgment that the plaintiff had not had his identity stolen, nor had he suffered any physical injury, harm, or lost wages as a result of DRN’s collection. Instead, the plaintiff testified that his only harm was that his “privacy ha[d] been violated on multiple occasions.”
The trial court held, and the Court of Appeal agreed, that actual harm was a necessary component of the statutory standing inquiry. First, under the plain language of the statute, only an individual “who has been harmed by a violation of the statute” has a private right of action to bring a lawsuit. The court concluded that the required harm must be distinct from the statutory violation itself. Because the plaintiff alleged only that the violation invaded his privacy, he failed to establish the requisite harm. The legislature also provided examples of harm in the text of the ALPR statute, including “unauthorized access or use of ALPR information or a breach of security of an ALPR system.” These examples go beyond a statutory violation.
Second, the legislative history supported that interpretation. One report from the legislative history referred to damages in actions brought by individuals harmed by the improper use of ALPR data, while another described claims by individuals whose information was unlawfully disclosed. Both examples involved misuse or disclosure of ALPR information—more than mere noncompliance with the statute.
The Mata court addressed Bartholomew and expressed skepticism about the “right to know” harm, but distinguished Bartholomew’s limited holding and confined it to businesses without an ALPR policy. In other words, if a business fails to draft and display a written ALPR policy, the absence of that policy may satisfy the statute’s harm requirement. In contrast, where a business adopts and conspicuously posts a written ALPR policy, then a plaintiff must show harm distinct from the asserted statutory violation, such as actual harm by the collection or use of the license plate data.
On August 5, 2026, a Northern District of California court added another decision supporting and adopting the Bartholomew analysis. In McGinity v. Reimagined Parking LLC,[4] the plaintiff claimed he parked in a lot that used ALPR technology but that did not have or post an ALPR usage policy. The court denied the parking lot operator’s motion to dismiss on the basis that the plaintiff “adequately alleged actionable harm to his ‘right to know’ about the use of ALPRs in the two garages at issue,” following the Bartholomew reasoning that failure to have a posted ALPR policy constituted “harm” under the statute. The court noted its confidence that the California Supreme Court would conclude that a violation of a consumer’s “right to know” would be an actionable harm under the ALPR statute.
Together, Bartholomew, Mata, and McGinity provide businesses with a clearer pathway of the ALPR law going forward. Businesses subject to the statute should promptly confirm that they have an ALPR policy in place. Doing so may reduce risk of lawsuits along the lines of Bartholomew and McGinity and will require plaintiffs to plead and prove actual harm beyond a mere statutory violation to succeed.
Additionally, because these ALPR lawsuits are on the rise, businesses that fall within the law’s purview should consider taking the following steps:
The recent wave of ALPR litigation shows that businesses may face legal claims not only arising from the collection or use of license plate data, but also from the absence of a posted, statute-compliant policy. After Barthlomew and McGinity, one of the most important steps businesses can take to reduce litigation exposure is to adopt and post a compliant ALPR policy.
If your company needs assistance with any privacy issues, Coblentz Data Privacy & Cybersecurity attorneys can help. Please contact Scott Hall at shall@coblentzlaw.com or Phillip Wiese at pwiese@coblentzlaw.com for further information or assistance.
[1] Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.90.5, et seq.
[2] 118 Cal. App. 5th 438 (2026).
[3] 121 Cal. App. 5th 1075 (2026).
[4] 2026 WL 2322918 (N.D. Cal. Aug. 5, 2026).