By Scott Hall and Katie Berens
For the last several years, the CIPA landscape has been defined by a surge of demand letters, inconsistent lower court rulings, a lack of appellate precedent, and continued uncertainty. But in mid-2026, two developments in CIPA litigation and reform introduced a new chapter for this now-popular statute—addressing certain long-standing questions, while raising several new ones. Companies should closely monitor these developments and continue to treat website tracking litigation as an evolving area of risk.
The California Invasion of Privacy Act of 1967 (CIPA), Cal. Penal Code §§ 630, et seq., is a criminal statute prohibiting the unauthorized interception or recording of communications. Although CIPA was historically understood to apply to wiretapping and eavesdropping on telephone calls, CIPA claims have exploded over the last several years, with plaintiffs bringing claims based on alleged violations involving modern website tools. Relying on the statute’s private right of action and statutory damages, plaintiffs have developed creative approaches and legal theories for alleged CIPA violations based on companies’ use of common website tracking technologies such as cookies, pixels, and other third-party analytics software.
Plaintiffs commonly bring CIPA claims under two of the statute’s provisions: (i) the wiretapping provision, § 631(a)), which prohibits intercepting communications without authorization; and (ii) the pen register and trap and trace provision, § 638.51(a), which prohibits using a pen register or trap and trace device without a court order. The statute provides for damages of up to $5,000 per violation under § 637.2, among other forms of civil relief, promoting the rise of this statute as a popular basis for individual and class action claims and often yielding low-effort settlements for plaintiffs.
For years, parties have contested in demand letter negotiations and state and federal courts whether a company’s use of a cookie or pixel on its website can qualify as illegal wiretapping, or as a pen register or “trap and trace” technology, in violation of CIPA. Without appellate guidance, courts have come out differently on these questions—resulting in unpredictable outcomes and ongoing uncertainty.
Two recent developments may finally bring some long-awaited answers and a clearer path forward—but will likely also lead to plaintiffs pivoting to new approaches to litigating the same alleged privacy violations under different theories and statutes.
On August 21, 2026, the California Court of Appeal issued its tentative ruling in the case of Variety Media, LLC v. Superior Court, No. B350578, which addressed whether internet-based tracking technology that collects information from visitors to a website qualifies as a “pen register” under CIPA.
The Court tentatively ruled that CIPA’s definition of “pen register” may include this type of technology, and is not limited to telephone monitoring devices—rejecting the decisions from many state-level trial courts that the Legislature did not intend this provision to apply to internet-based technology. The Court also appears ready to deny the frequently asserted argument that applying CIPA’s pen register provisions to internet communications would create an irreconcilable conflict with the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), declaring that CIPA’s consent requirement incorporates and exceeds the CCPA’s requirements, rather than displacing them.
But the Court also gave hope to businesses, tentatively ruling that the collection of an IP address alone is not enough to support a CIPA pen register claim, because an IP address only identifies the source of the communication, not its destination as the pen register provision requires.
Because the Court has only issued a tentative ruling, this is not yet settled law. But the Court’s comments during the August 21 oral argument largely indicated that it is inclined to adopt its tentative ruling. If the Court adopts the ruling, this would resolve several longstanding debates on CIPA claims—at nearly the same time that CIPA reform finally passed in the Legislature.
On September 30, 2026, California Governor Gavin Newsom signed into law SB 690, a long-awaited bill that eliminates the private right of action under CIPA’s pen register/trap and trace provision (§ 638.51) so that it may only be enforced by the California Attorney General. SB 690 would apply retroactively to any actions filed within two years prior to its effective date of January 1, 2027.
Earlier versions of SB 690 provided for more substantial changes, including proposed amendments to §§ 631, 632, 632.7, and 638.50, that would have defined website analytics and marketing tools as disclosures made for a “commercial business purpose” and thus exempt from the law. This would have brought relief to a greater range of CIPA claims, including wiretapping claims, based on website tracking technologies beyond pen register and trap and trace claims. But the final version is far narrower, and does not include the “commercial business purpose” exemption.
Even so, the law as passed will still bring relief to companies who have faced a deluge of threatened and filed CIPA pen register claims in recent years.
Because SB 690 does not cover CIPA’s wiretapping provision (§ 631(a)), these types of claims are expected to continue and increase even after SB 690 takes effect, along with other similar statutory and common-law privacy claims. Plaintiffs are also likely to continue bringing website-technology claims under other statutes including the Video Privacy Protection Act (VPPA), Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA), Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA), California Comprehensive Data Access and Fraud Act (CDAFA), and more.
Companies should remain vigilant and continue to mitigate these risks by conducting regular audits and reviews of tracking technologies employed, consent flows, vendor contracts, and privacy notices. Companies should also confirm that any cookies, pixels, or other third-party analytics tools on their websites are used and operating as described in their privacy disclosures. At this time, the best practice to avoid these claims is to refrain from placing cookies or pixels until a user has affirmatively accepted them. Although this practice is not required by the CCPA, and may not be the right business decision for all companies, it appears at the moment to keep plaintiffs from sending demand letters and bringing suit.
Fall Privacy Webinar – November 17, 2026
Join Scott Hall and members of the Coblentz Data Privacy Team on Tuesday, November 17, 2026 for a timely discussion of the latest developments shaping the privacy, cybersecurity, and AI landscape and what they mean for your business. Learn practical steps to manage risk and gain insight into emerging state and federal AI developments; new and amended consumer privacy laws; enforcement trends involving children’s and sensitive data; and key privacy litigation and regulatory developments. RSVP for the webinar here.
If your company needs assistance with any privacy issues, Coblentz Data Privacy & Cybersecurity attorneys can help. Please contact Scott Hall at shall@coblentzlaw.com for further information or assistance.